My husband unexpectedly purchased a red dress for his sister-in-law, claiming it was her birthday, even though he had ignored his own wife’s birthday just two days earlier. When I uncovered the truth about him, the pain was unbearable.
Two days ago was my birthday. My husband – Arjun Sharma – merely texted me a short “Happy Birthday” before heading off to work. No flowers, no gift, no dinner. I comforted myself: “He must be swamped, let it go.”
But this afternoon, when I stepped into my flat in Andheri, a large box was on the sofa. Inside lay a striking red dress. Before I could question him, Arjun smiled and said:
“Oh, this dress is for Priya – my sister-in-law. It’s her birthday tomorrow.”
I froze. Priya—the wife of Rohan, Arjun’s younger brother. He remembered her special day every year without fail, but somehow forgot his own wife’s.
That night I couldn’t sleep. The vision of Arjun holding that red dress haunted me. Suspicion gnawed at me.
The first clue was the receipt: it was dated last week—right before my birthday. Secretly, I checked Arjun’s phone and found WhatsApp messages:
Arjun: “This dress will look stunning on you, try it tomorrow.”
Priya: “I’m afraid someone might see us…”
Arjun: “Don’t worry, I’ll be there.”
My hands trembled, and I decided to follow him.
The next day, pretending to leave work early, I parked outside a café in Bandra. Inside, Arjun and Priya sat close together; Priya wore the very same red dress. Their expressions were far from those of in-laws.
I quietly snapped a photo, my chest hollow. That night at home, I laid the picture on the table in silence. Arjun saw it, his face draining of color. Rohan entered, spotted the photo, and both brothers froze.
In that moment, I realized: the red dress wasn’t an innocent gift, but proof of a secret long hidden enough to destr0y two families.
The air thickened; only the clock ticked. Rohan, shaking, asked:
“Brother… with my wife… what?”
Arjun bowed, silent. Priya broke into sobs:
“I’m… sorry…”
I forced calm into my voice:
“I want the whole truth.”
Arjun exhaled deeply and admitted: before marrying me, he had briefly dated Priya, the neighbor’s daughter. She later wed Rohan. I thought it ended, but once she became my sister-in-law, they kept meeting. At first just greetings, then small favors, then secret coffee outings.
The red dress… wasn’t merely a present. In his gallery, I found a photo of them strolling on a Goan beach a month earlier, when Arjun had claimed he was away on “business.”
Rohan paled, horrified. As for me, fury rose, but not a single tear came. I stood and declared:
“From this moment, I am not your wife.”
I walked out, leaving behind voices raised in anger, weeping, and the sound of a family shattering—all triggered by that red dress.
That rainy night, leaving my flat in Andheri, I rode in the back of an auto-rickshaw, clutching my bag like the last shred of pride. The red in that photo flashed in my mind—the same hue as my wedding dupatta, but now it symbolized warning.
The following morning, I returned. Not to stay, but to set matters straight.
1) Family confrontation at the Sharma home
My mother-in-law, Sarla Devi, gathered us on the terrace where papadam usually dried. Today, no small talk. Arjun sat wordless, Rohan leaned on the railing, and Priya twisted her hands until her knuckles whitened.
I laid envelopes on the table: the receipt, the café photos, the Goa ticket.
I faced Arjun:
“Speak. In front of your mother, in front of your brother.”
Arjun drew a breath:
“I… was wrong. It started with casual chats, but I crossed the line. I thought I had control, but I didn’t.”
Rohan ground his teeth:
“Brother, before marriage, were you and she…?”
Arjun nodded:
“There was a spark. We ended it. I assumed it was gone.”
Priya sobbed:
“I’m sorry. I tried resisting, but every quarrel with Rohan… drove me toward him.”
Sarla Devi slammed the table:
“In this house, better to separate than to live on lies. Trust once broken cannot be forced.”
I turned to Rohan:
“What do you want? I’ll support you.”
Rohan swallowed:
“I want honesty and respect. The rest, I’ll decide.”
2) Three documents and a mangalsutra
I produced three papers:
Temporary separation between Arjun and me for six months.
Agreement: no private contact between Arjun and Priya, or else we proceed to court.
Financial settlement: all joint savings to my name, payment for months of betrayal.
Then I placed my mangalsutra down:
“If you meet her again, I will divorce you. I remove this not because I reject marriage, but to protect my dignity.”
Arjun signed, pale. His mother turned away, shaking. Priya signed too, whispering:
“I’m sorry, sister-in-law. I’ll return to my mother’s house for now.”
Rohan folded the papers:
“I’ll explain to our parents later.”
Weeks later, Priya summoned me to Juhu Beach. She brought the red dress, washed and folded.
“I’m returning it, not to you, but to my conscience.”
I stared at the waves:
“You can give back the dress—but how about trust?”
Priya’s eyes were swollen:
“I’ll work elsewhere, far from him. Rohan told me to think for myself. I don’t ask your pardon, only that you don’t hate yourself for trusting wrongly.”
The sea breeze lifted the skirt. I said:
“Burn it—not to erase, but to end it.”
We lit it with dry sticks; the red flared, then faded.
That evening Arjun emailed me proof he had enrolled in an ethics course. Standing outside, he murmured:
“I don’t beg forgiveness. Just a chance to restore what I stole—your peace.”
I shut the door. I was tired, but steadier. Time would reveal everyone’s path.
Later, Rohan met me at a tea stall. His eyes rimmed red, he whispered:
“I won’t harm them. I’ll just stop. If after six months I still want to stop, I’ll sign. Otherwise… I’ll move on. I refuse to be a shadow of a dress.”
I replied softly:
“Don’t become a shadow of anger either. You deserve better.”
He gave a sad smile:
“I’ll try to be a man of my own story, not a victim of theirs.”
Life resumed. I rented a small flat in Powai, joined yoga, learned driving, and reminded myself daily: “Today, I live for me.”
Months later, my mother-in-law said:
“If you want divorce now, I’ll support you.”
I answered:
“Mom, if my heart stays unchanged, I’ll sign then. I’m not waiting for healing, just delaying judgment.”
In the fourth month, Priya wrote: she moved in with her parents, took counseling, requested a transfer. “If Rohan and I reconcile, it will be new, not recycled. If not, I’ll still live.”
By the sixth month, Arjun left a box at my door: property transferred to me, along with resignation papers. A note read: “If you sign, I won’t resist. If you stay, I’ll restart with boundaries.”
I placed the papers on a small altar, lit incense, and thanked myself for surviving half a year with dignity.
Courtroom – My decision
At Bandra Family Court, dressed simply in white, I faced the judge. Arjun sat apart, head lowered.
“Do you wish to reconcile?” the judge asked.
I thought of the red dress, Juhu flames, Irani tea, his emails, my mother-in-law’s tears, my daily mantra. My heart answered clearly:
“Your Honor, I choose… freedom.”
Arjun lifted his eyes, wet but silent, and nodded. Outside, Rohan waited. He asked:
“Are you okay?”
“I am. And you?”
“I’m fine too. Whatever happens, I won’t betray you.”
I smiled faintly. The Mumbai sun spilled gold through coconut trees.